Memo to Members

Rental Assistance Demonstration Program Could Create Displaceability

Nov 16, 2026

By Elizabeth Workman, NLIHC Research Intern 

An article published in Housing Studies, “Displaceability under the Rental Assistance Demonstration (RAD): Theory, Evidence, and Future Directions,” examines whether, despite its statutory anti-displacement protections, the RAD program could still generate displaceability. “Displaceability” refers to vulnerability to displacement even when residents have the legal right to stay. The author points to three ways RAD might do so: discontinuation of flat-rent options, neighborhood change because of reinvestment, and discretionary enforcement of resident protections by non-public partners. 

This study emphasizes that RAD protections successfully prevent direct large-scale displacement. Since 2011, RAD has allowed public housing authorities to convert public housing from its traditional federal funding system to long-term, project-based Section 8 rental assistance contracts. These contracts provide a more stable and politically sustainable source of subsidy, which owners can leverage to raise debt and equity for renovation and preservation. To prevent displacement, RAD requires that conversion cannot be used as the basis of eviction and that, after renovations, incumbent tenants cannot be treated as “new admissions.” This study concludes that RAD’s right-to-remain is effective in preventing large-scale displacement, as the 2019 HUD evaluation revealed that 92% of surveyed residents returned to the same property after RAD conversion. 

While tenant protections within the RAD program appear to mitigate displacement during and immediately after the conversion process, this study focuses on the displaceability RAD creates. HUD’s 2019 evaluation also revealed that after RAD conversion, about half of the residents surveyed reported an increase in rent, with 36% reporting an increase in utilities as well. When properties are converted through RAD, residents who had previously chosen flat rent, a fixed amount that does not rise with income, are forced to pay income-based rent instead. Households typically chose flat rent because it was lower than 30% of their income, so switching to income-based rent can mean a sizable increase, which may strain households with little financial cushion. Additionally, management of RAD properties typically shifts to a non-public institution whose central priority is often rent collection. Non-public RAD partners face pressure to meet financing requirements and maintain a steady revenue stream and are therefore less likely to tolerate tenants struggling to pay rent. Furthermore, the shift in property management through RAD conversion is often multi-layered and technically dense, leading to residents not understanding their right-to-remain. Residents sometimes view the Choice Mobility voucher element of RAD as a push to leave, when it is intended as only a mechanism to allow residents to choose to move to better neighborhoods if they want to. 

In addition to displaceability created within RAD properties themselves, the author also argues that RAD conversion may foster displaceability through neighborhood change. RAD conversion signals reinvestment opportunities in neighborhoods that increase the cost of living for residents. This reinvestment eventually attracts wealthier residents, driving up overall costs for original tenants. The author points out that in one New York City study, 2/3 of block groups with public housing were surrounded by block groups with average incomes above the city median, making neighborhoods with public housing readily accessible to higher-income movers. Also, such neighborhood growth can erase the cultural community to which many residents are strongly attached. Loss of community, by forces beyond the tenant’s control, can contribute to the feeling of being pushed to leave after RAD conversion.   

Overall, the author finds no evidence that the RAD program facilitates large-scale displacement, but that it contains several factors that may foster displaceability. The author does not believe that displaceability warrants a discontinuation of RAD and instead suggests policy changes to limit tenants’ vulnerability to displacement. Such protections include requiring plain-language notices of management changes caused by RAD conversion, more support for residents who are temporarily relocated during construction, and assessment of broader neighborhood effects of reinvestment. The author cautions against accepting displaceability as a trade-off to slow neighborhood decline. Finally, the author suggests that further research is needed, particularly on how displaceability varies by different RAD organizational arrangements (such as national or local developers, nonprofit contribution, or other arrangements). 

Read the full report.